Hanazakari no Kimitachi e • Hana-Kimi - Episode 1 discussion
*Hanazakari no Kimitachi e*, episode 1
**Reminder:** Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
---
**Streams**
*None*
**Show information**
* [MyAnimeList](https://myanimelist.net/anime/58861/)
* [AniList](https://anilist.co/anime/177580)
* [AniDB](https://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=18636)
* [Kitsu](https://kitsu.app/anime/48870)
* [Anime-Planet](https://www.anime-planet.com/anime/hana-kimi)
* [Official Website](https://hanakimi-anime.com/)
---
**All discussions**
Episode|Link
:-:|:-:
1|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q3qtm3)
2|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q3qtmc)
---
*This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments.*
*The original source code can be found on [GitHub](https://github.com/r-anime/holo).*
**Reminder:** Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
---
**Streams**
*None*
**Show information**
* [MyAnimeList](https://myanimelist.net/anime/58861/)
* [AniList](https://anilist.co/anime/177580)
* [AniDB](https://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=18636)
* [Kitsu](https://kitsu.app/anime/48870)
* [Anime-Planet](https://www.anime-planet.com/anime/hana-kimi)
* [Official Website](https://hanakimi-anime.com/)
---
**All discussions**
Episode|Link
:-:|:-:
1|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q3qtm3)
2|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q3qtmc)
---
*This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments.*
*The original source code can be found on [GitHub](https://github.com/r-anime/holo).*
Commentaires
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original, or just general talk about the source material. **You are still required to tag all spoilers.** Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
`[Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<`
# **All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).**
[](#emptyinside)
I'm glad that your seminal work can finally be adapted into anime with so much care and love.
It'd be great if we got an entire adaptation!
I really hope that this anime does the manga and the author justice, especially if we can get a full adaptation. It's off to a great start so far, here's hoping it can keep up the quality.
The doggy is super cute
I love switching back from EN when they’re in the US to JP when we’re now in Japan. Still remember the Great Pretender doing that embedded into the episode. I kinda wish they did that here for the beginning.
I did not expect this to be the sound of the OP. But YOASOBI supremacy.
And they were roommates!
*Oh my god, they’re roommates.*
The gender-sniffing dog. Doggo can be the most gender-affirming creature, outs you, or denies your gender.
How did they even get that many pictures…
Would that be mpreg? I mean… The mpreg is implied, but it’s still just pregnancy since Ashiya is a lady. But also, I won’t turn down mpreg…
Izumi is such a cutie when he smiles.
I love that the captains sound like obsessed LIs 😭 They are on a manhunt.
Rest in peace, Hisaya Nakajo. You died too young, but you will not be forgotten ❤️
She died of heart disease in 2023 (🔗 [**Hakusensha JP**](https://www.hakusensha.co.jp/information/69254/) & [**ANN EN**](https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2023-10-26/hana-kimi-creator-hisaya-nakajo-passes-away-at-50/.203814)) at 50 😞
***
Excited to hear Umehara (Nanba). He’s also voicing Gil from <A Gentle Noble’s Vacation Recommendation> and ✨Aquasteed Marineforest✨from <The Villainess is Adored by the Prince of the Neighbor Kingdom>, so I’m excited for his appearances in those too.
Wow, an Actual haircut. Not like that Vampire dormitory nonsense. Though it seems I have an attraction towards a certain appearance. *Yes, that includes Yuu.*
I would call it a friendship speedrun. But does it count if the true intention is different?
I get the vibe that Mizuki was smitten at first sight to Sano but hadn't quite figured out the distinction between admiration/respect and love by this point. Also she's used to American relationships so she probably thinks just starting as friends is how courtships usually work instead of confessions.
As for the anime itself, I felt it was okay. The art is good and the characters are pretty decent. Not sure how I feel about Mizuki's motivations in enrolling in the first place, her actions come across as stalker-ish to me. I think I will give this a little more time to see if I get into it.
not just-ish, this is full blown mentally-ill stalking. She literally saw someone on TV, moved countries, faked her gender to attend an all boys school all just to get close to the guy she saw on TV.
Even for anime that's *wild*
Some tropes just didn't age well and the FL definitely is strange/stalkerish but I'm curious about her in general. Moving overseas to attend an all-boys school is pretty wild.
That ending tribute, though. Hit me right in the feels.
certain quips felt cut out or re-phrased… reactions missing… lack of background music really made it feel hollow. It has so much potential but my immediate vibe of the anime is that it’s taking itself too seriously??? some of the sillier lines and moments that stayed in didn’t hit hard because there was lack of build up, or no background sounds to emphasize or make it come across in a silly way. making those moments read as awkward or weird instead.
I rewatched an episode of fruits basket, and ouran afterwards. for both I really realized it’s the lack of music and sound effects. like take those out of those two shows and you’ll get the hana kimi anime. imagine Ouran without its bouncy classic music… except for during emotional moments and it’s played way too quietly.
[I already like this kansai-ben dude.](https://i.imgur.com/6vsiFXJ.png) It's been barely a day [and he's already asking personal questions.](https://i.imgur.com/kTrydb9.png)
[This girl has absolutely no filter, and it's hilarious!](https://i.imgur.com/zdnRNNo.png) I wonder if she even realizes what she's doing.
No surprise that [the all-boys dorm is already praising Mizuki as the new idoi](https://i.imgur.com/OMic210.png).
[Girl is so in love that she can't even stop herself from trying to kiss Sano while he's napping](https://i.imgur.com/CfpoN6K.png)
[There it is.](https://i.imgur.com/sLHcKdD.png) There was no way that the doctor wouldn't notice. Also, I think Sano already noticed, too.
Welp, that was fun! HanaKimi is one of those series that I've heard about since the 2000s (I know it's a 90s manga), but I never really got into it since it wasn't really my kind of manga back then. I'm glad that this anime adaptation exists, so I can finally give it a shot.
With that said, is it just me or did anyone else feel this was just an "Okay" episode? Considering the impact this series had on the genre, I was expecting a bit more. Like, they got YOASOBI to do the opening and ending, but the overall presentation didn't quite hit the mark. I'm still gonna watch this because I am curious about the story, I just wish the visuals and animation had more impact.
I mean, she nearly stole a kiss and it's already episode 1 lol.
I noticed he said yorosh**uu** (よろしゅう spelling?) rather than yoroshi**ku** (よろしく) I wouldn't be able to pick out what's kansai-ben and what's slang.
Side note, the credits have an actual Kansai-ben consultant which is kinda hilarious to me.
I imagine it would have taken more than a few chapters at the beginning to earn that reputation. Let's give it time.
I had to look it up afterwards and was not surprised to see the source material being from the 90s, shit was crazy back then.
Feels nice to reunite with all the characters and see them animated/hear them voiced. Really loving the main trio so far, they're more or less how I imagined they'd sound like back when I first read this.
Fun to see things from Mizuki's POV in the OP.
Nice to see Nakatsu be quick to befriend Mizuki and get chummy with her. Sano not so much, but at least he's slowly warming up.
Wish Nakajo-sensei was around to see this, R.I.P.
Looking at the cast list, I'm delighted that the VA for Subaru from *Fragrant Flower* is now surrounded by guys, and that her first friend is voiced by Usami's VA.
I'm really happy to see Aya Yamane headlining her own Shojo anime!
Yeah, that's when it got too much for me so I dropped at that point.
They did justice to all characters. They all look super cool. Especially Izumi. Also I didn't recall Nakatsu speaking in accent but now that i heard him speak he feels more friendly/cheerful now which is really in character for him.
Tbh it freaked me out when i first read the manga and saw Mizuki going to all boys school just to meet Izumi but now it didn't bug me any bit. I found it inspirational, even. I'm sure we'll get to know about her source of admiration soon enough. For now, i'm just rooting for her to survive in an all boys school&dorm!
Yoasobi OP! Featuring Mizuki chasing Sano, all the handsome men in her life, her supporting cast, and just a really fun, cute, Shojo OP!
Classic Shojo romcom moment: be late for school, bump into the male lead, immediately have him clock how girlish she is, and end up in the same classes together! Though she kind of jumps the gun a little "confessing" her feelings (and desire for friendship) to Sano (Taku Yashiro) and making everything think she's the class gay kid.
But even if she kind of struck out with Sano, at least she gets off to a good start with Nakatsu (Kikunosuke Toya!) who is a friendly blonde bro who wants to talk about how Americans "pleasure" themselves! And "Dr. Sadist" AKA Umeda (Jun Fukuyama!).
Yeah, she's doing a great job maintaining her cover as a girl pretending to be a boy, what with Nakatsu already seeing her as girlish, the girl-friendly dog Yujiro being all over her, and her seemingly flat chest fooling Nakatsu. She's not sure how to feel about that last one.
Oh of COURSE she's going to be roommates with Sano. Too bad that the high-jump ace she fell for and that she followed all the way to an all-boys school...is not doing the high-jump anymore, the thing she admired most about him.
Also at the dorm is Kayashina (Kouki Uchiyama!), the dorm RA Nanba (Yuichiro Umehara!) who Mizuki better hope doesn't find out she's a girl because he seems like a womanizer, and Nakao (Reiji Kawashima!) who against Mizuki's own desire she's now in competition with for school idol. And this is only her first day!
Sano may not be high-jumping any more but that's not going to stop Mizuki from getting a little TOO cozy with him while he's dozing off next to a tree...she just can't help herself! And so of course Yujiro pushes them together so they're on top of each other. I mean, this IS a classic Shojo after all.
Take a shot every time Mizuki finds Sano sleeping! Though this time she REALLY tries to kiss him while he's asleep because she can't help herself.
Wow, Mizuki's track skills are legit! Enough to where she beats the best boy record and ALL the clubs want her to join up! Good thing she's fast enough to outrun them, but Nakatsu has too much pride to let Mizuki beat his running time without a fight...even if that means a soccer match with Mizuki that ends with her hurt.
Well, Mizuki would probably appreciate being princess carried by Sano (even if he may or may not have realized something from touching her body), but Umeda has figured her out!
Nice tribute to Hisaya Nakajo-sensei at the end.
I’m gonna have to watch this when this airing ends
Apparently there was also a Kdrama version too, starring Choi Minho and the late Sulli.
The 2007 version is generally considered the better version of the j-drama
I feel a bit bad for Sano suddenly getting this roommate that is way too obsessed with him.
Very good dog.
Wait. This is the famous Hana-Kimi?? Ok, I have to watch this, and forgive it its old tropes, so long as it doesn't get rapey.
- This belongs in the Source Material Corner at the top of this thread. In discussion threads for currently airing anime, discussions about
source material, spin-offs, and unadapted content must be posted there, and not outside it. This applies specifically to comparisons to the anime or hints about future events, even if such hints are vague.
Please note that you still have to tag your spoilers in the source corner.
For more info about what is a spoiler, please check out our [full rule page section.](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/wiki/rules#wiki_do_not_post_untagged_spoilers).
---
^(Have a question or think this removal was an error?) **[^(Message the mods.)](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2Fanime)**
^(Don't know the rules? Read them )**[^(here)](/r/anime/wiki/rules)**^.
I wonder why this didn't get an anime adaptation for so long despite getting a live action. I wish the mangaka Hisaya Nakajo was alive to see this.
This reminds me more of the movie 'She's the man' but Hana-Kimi actually seems to predate this movie.
Yoasobi is doing the op and ed.. perfect ✨❤️
Mizuki getting caught in the first episode lol didn't see that coming. You can't really fool the eyes of a doctor. Asano also seems to have caught on to her identity.
Nakatsu saying talking to Nanba would get Mizuki pregnant was amusing lol, I like that Nanba overheard it.
It is awkward to see how proactive Mizuki is about getting close to Sano, they don't really know each other so her watching him sleep was a bit much for me.
I got a lot to thank Hana Kimi's impact for since who knows if Ouran Highschool Host Club would've even existed without it.
There are other crossdressing stories that I like a lot too like Caught by the Villain, The Kings Beast, Jack Jeanne and Psychedelica of the Ashen Hawk. Definitely more that I just can't remember right now.
Kinda crazy that's it's only getting an anime now. May the mangaka rest in peace.
It's looking like a decent adaption! I love the quality Tamon is getting this season, but this is serviceable too. At least compared to some unfortunate shoujo adaptions I have suffered through (what did they do to you 7 Seeds...).
It will be nice to revisit this story even if due to it's age and influence on other works it won't feel new.
They nailed the vibe and the production was better than I was expecting. My best boy Nakatsu lives again!
This first episode was so nostalgic and reminded me why I love these characters.
Edit: forgot to add the feels when I saw the tribute to Nakajo Hisaya-sensei. RIP 🕊️
That was a very quick love confession.
What did Blondie mean by "Do they go harder over there"? Sex stuff? Harder than what?
"The bath in your room is off-limits after midnight." That would certainly be extremely annoying.
Too much cringe for me in this one, so I'm stopping 2/3 into the ep.
Somehow I feel she omitted that little detail from her explanation.
And we have England from hetalia in this series
And of course she ran right into him...
Gee what a coincidence...
Ok...
Gee how convenient...
Of all the people to be rooming with...
Lol she's starting at him sleeping...
Lol every club is chomping at the bit to recruit her after she pulled that off.
Bruh she's trying to kiss him.
Uh oh, he knocked her out!
Well, that was quick.
Engrish...