Yuusha Party wo Oidasareta Kiyou binbou • Jack-of-All-Trades, Party of None - Episode 4 discussion
*Yuusha Party wo Oidasareta Kiyou binbou*, episode 4
**Reminder:** Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
---
**Streams**
* [Crunchyroll](http://crunchyroll.com/series/GT00366764)
**Show information**
* [MyAnimeList](https://myanimelist.net/anime/61128/)
* [AniList](https://anilist.co/anime/187264)
* [AniDB](https://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=19190)
* [Official Website](https://kiyou-bimbou.com/)
---
**All discussions**
Episode|Link
:-:|:-:
1|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q0f5ow)
2|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q6ho5p)
3|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1qcpjyv)
4|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1qj0b20)
---
*This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments.*
*The original source code can be found on [GitHub](https://github.com/r-anime/holo).*
**Reminder:** Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
---
**Streams**
* [Crunchyroll](http://crunchyroll.com/series/GT00366764)
**Show information**
* [MyAnimeList](https://myanimelist.net/anime/61128/)
* [AniList](https://anilist.co/anime/187264)
* [AniDB](https://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=19190)
* [Official Website](https://kiyou-bimbou.com/)
---
**All discussions**
Episode|Link
:-:|:-:
1|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q0f5ow)
2|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1q6ho5p)
3|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1qcpjyv)
4|[Link](https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1qj0b20)
---
*This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments.*
*The original source code can be found on [GitHub](https://github.com/r-anime/holo).*
Commentaires
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original, or just general talk about the source material. **You are still required to tag all spoilers.** Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
`[Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<`
# **All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).**
There's no saving Oliver.
They say that the 50x thing is an original skill that he uses to "make up for his weaknesses" but if you do so by just directly buffing yourself at the thing you're weak at you're not "making up for your weakness" anymore, you just became stronger.
I feel like it would have been more interesting if they focused more on the aspect of him enchanting weapons and spells instead of the person directly, rather than just having him be 5 times more powerful than the next best enchanter.
Meaning, if you can't let go of your pride, a fall from grace is inevitable.
Anyway, he's definitely delusional if he thinks he can keep going with the party in this state.
The healer girl should just leave that party, I don't know why she didn't leave it already, probably because she wants to make a party with Orhun but he wants to be left alone for now, but if she stay in that party she could end up dead because of a bunch of arrogant dumbass (we know that she won't die, most author would never do that).
Edit: Since they brought up the finances, this will definitely see them struggle with it later, since they won't have anyone to manage and will just spend the money.
The other two that aren't childhood friends are the rudest towards Orhun.
When they mentioned the penalty for the forced teleportation I'm guessing that they would have to pay a high price for that, I bet that'll wipe out the savings they had on top of everything else going wrong for them lol.
Something that Orhun and the Healer within the party also knew...
This was inevitable.
The talk about finances is another huge red flag. Adventuring is gig work, that lacks a steady revenue stream (IE salary). It's also a dangerous job where shit is guaranteed to happen. You need to keep a sizeable "rainy day" fund for dry spells or just whenever something comes up.
All in all, this Hero's party really is too stupid to live. I fully understand what the Healer said about "Orhun finally gave up on US," as they really are dead weight that Orhun had to go above and beyond to work around.
IE: Their success was in spite of their best efforts, not directly because of it. But their ego and ignorance meant they could only see the "paper" value of Orhun's rank, A-class, and just assume these metrics are deterministic and objective values instead of rough approximations.
All while ignoring the evidence of their own eyes... because of pride.
The new Enchanter should bounce and the Healer should leave with her.
Honestly I'd say the assumptions come from not seeing Orhun study, probably even staying up at night to do it, so just plain stupidity.
Lol
>A-class
He was S tho, they just called him A class as an insult.
They are ego-tripping assholes, in other words.
It's also why they keep deriding him as a "Jack of all trades, master of none." He's A-rank in many abilities, but lacks any S-rank qualifications.
But yes, he was apart of an S-ranked party despite not having S-ranked abiltiies.
The fact that the legendary genius Enchanter that revolutionized how the game is played views Orhun as better than her... means there is a **serious** flaw in how ability is quantified.
But the "Heroes" couldn't begin to accept this because that would mean admitting the "lesser" being isn't actually "lesser" than them. They'd have to reevaluate their own self-worth, and they would rather commit suicide-via-stupidity than admit they were the scrubs getting carried.
And we do learn something new: the hero party is in fact so bad: the hero is not compatible to be buffed, the Magician is too used to do easy mid class magic, the armour guy can't even do his work without buffed armour, nobody can strategize without Orhun.
Sometimes in story like this, the rest of the party itself is not really bad, they just become so much better (or gel together) with MC. This one the hero himself would not be able to join other party if he's that hard to be buffed.
We learned that there's an OP floor boss that's smart enough to not only leave his boss room but to also know how to use the party's escape gates to portal to the upper levels of the dungeon.
Plus it's common knowledge in the setting that bosses do not leave their boss rooms. If Ohrun knew otherwise, then he would've been obligated to let the entire adventurer's guild know about that.
I think she still wanted to have faith that Oliver would see sense before she saw him really double down in this episode.
Philly also assumed the Hero's Party would be a solid gig because of their reputation without realizing what she was really signing on for. So she needs to ditch them too.
I mean he can self buff to a ridiculous degree so without having to carry his ex party its probably going to be doable for him.
She should've left during that meeting. "I don't want to die." "You aren't allowed to refuse."
"I'm not allowed to refuse? Dafuq you gonna do, kill me? Go find another healer instead, you had no trouble replacing Orhun, I'm sure you other great healer candidates at your beck and call."
It’s almost laughable how stupid the party was being minus Luna and Philly. They couldn’t take down the mammoth, but they thought they could take the dragon? Despite Oliver realizing they’re weaker too. Idiots. And they basically let that shit loose. Let’s see how badly Oliver’s pride continues to screw everyone.
- Dragon comes in and squashes the mammoth like a bug.
"We can beat the dragon for sure"
I wanted those 3 to die so bad
The entire premise is that he was weak because he had weak magic and therefore did lesser amounts of buffing. If a normal enchanter could raise your strength 50 and a powerful one could raise it 100, he could raise it like 40.
But what they explained this episode is basically the exact opposite. That, because of his original spells having a higher multiplier, he'd be raising their strength like 300 instead AND have other significant bonuses.
Trash show, trash writing. I'll see you here next week as I continue to watch lol.
Typically you can get away with just a healer but it's soooo much easier with a dedicated support!
Luna should have said "oh, so you're saying it's a mandatory party event? I'll leave the party if that's the case. I'm a first-rate healer, I'll get paid enough at any other A-rank or above party, you guys can have all the dying to yourselves."
Doing anything else just shows Luna is not right in the head either.
She and Philly deserved better than this.
Even outsiders like Selma and her guild master could realize this truth: Orhun was hard-carrying his party.
So there is no excuse for the party itself not to realize the sudden increase in their fortunes was traced back to one guy switching roles.
But if the party was smart, capable, or just generally had an IQ above room temperature, then the plot couldn't happen.
This writing is painful. In fact, every 'kicked out of party' I have ever come across has been like this. Is there one anime like this that actually has a half competent script? Where the characters / old party etc. isnt comically inept and unbelievable, like a high ranked party should be?
Because if the banished 'protagonist' wasn't some misunderstood prodigy and the party had a good reason to kick them...
Then the wish fulfilment of rubbing your bully's nose in shit couldn't happen!
That's all these are. Shallow wish fulfilment where you get to experience petty revenge against the stupid people that wronged you for stupid reasons suffer horribly while a harem of hot chicks appears out of nowhere to glaze your 'Mighty Excalibur.'
If any of it was well written or well thought out, then you'd have to accept you were bullied for a good reason, or an acceptable one at least, that you were seriously flawed in some way, that the bullies are people worthy of respect and empathy as well, and that you need to put in the hard work to change yourself into a person worthy of esteem.
But fuck all that gay shit. You are already prefect! And the reason those shit heads couldn't see it is because they are sub-human troglodytes! You've done nothing wrong! You deserve to be angry and need the entire world to recognize that! Without any critical thinking or introspection or change or none of that hard and painful stuff!
That's all these shows are.
These series and isekai's too just follow what feels like a procedurally generated format that has check boxes and they're all just trash lol. Just exposition dumps, and telling the same story the exact same way over and over
Except that one is sensible in that everyone valued their personal skills except one who viciously lied and sold the protagonist into slavery where they finally understand their absurdly OP skill in a reasonable way. It's pretty neat so far!
"Banished from the Hero's Party, I Decided to Live a Quiet Life in the Countryside": Here, the MC is becoming substantially weaker than the rest. It was his excellent administrative skills that got overlooked. Also, only one jealous party member kicked him out (to get a better shot at a relationship with a girl in the party), and just pretended to speak for the rest. The rest of the party never would have agreed to kicking him out, had they known.
"Roll Over and Die: I will fight for an Ordinary Life with my Love and my Cursed Sword": (New anime this season, but I read some of the LN a few years back.): (Details shown here only cover Ep.1): Similar to above, kicked out by one party member, who pretended to speak for the rest. Also, she was legitimately weak, with a crippling negative ability. It was only after being kicked out that she discovered how to use her self-crippling ability in a way that would give her power.
Honorable Mention: Now, I will say that "The Banished Court Magician Aims to Become the Strongest" is more believable than most, since he is kicked out by a spoiled child prince who is just way to full of himself, instead of multiple supposed-to-be-mature adventurers in most such anime.
Luna must leave them and let them wipe.
One hand I enjoyed the rubbing it in, other hand I feel like a decent amount of screen time was wasted.
Funny how she said “he gave up on us” cue seeing all that food
I Parry Everything gets a bad rap but I believed why he thought he was useless due to a hilarious series of misunderstandings. These guys get a tragic series of truth bombs and more exposition than any one show can handle and they still think they’ve got this.
Question is, when a trio of children manage to defeat the black dragon with the jack of all trades’ advice, will the Hero Party still be able to convince themselves he’s no good?
It looks like she wanted him to get a reality check, sadly he is delusional so that didn't really work out.
This was already pretty shallow. We've seen the song and dance of people undeservedly going unappreciated before. That slum healer anime where the guy can solo the verse and then heal everyone after, the misfit of demon academy that clowns on gods and toys with reality itself, the irregular at magic high school who has at least three secret identities off the top of my head (secretly a member of the top family, a walking WMD in the special forces, the famous inventor)... the list goes on.
All of those had some reason (however shallow) for them being underestimated. The slum healer kid didn't have formal training or a license, the misfit of demon academy is a half-blood muggle or whatever, and Batman three cowls deep (the irregular at magic high school) had his power level read by a really shitty scouter.
In comes this show. The singular thing that it's reasonable for him to be deficient in, the magnitude of his buffs, is chucked out of the window when they say that he's five times stronger than the person said to be the strongest enchanter in the world.
We're supposed to be ragebaited against the hero party, but when they threw that out there, whatever rage I felt toward them was instantly shifted to the people who greenlit this thing to be animated.
They omitted it but all I can say is it it's not as straightforward. There is downside to it. Probably they will show it in the future.
But it was kind of funny seeing people cheer them on while they're running like idiots.
I understand conceptually that arrogance and ignorance can make some shitty people, but the description of events in this episode requires Orhun to be so immensely perfect from the start and 3/4 of his party members to never communicate or pay attention to anyone else on the planet. It also needs Orhun to be the kind of person that can innovate in a field to a prodigious level without being able to explain it or compare himself to others.
Blah, these banishment plotlines have so much potential for exploring characters and relationships. I keep tuning in with charitability that gets wasted.
By 50 perhaps?
Also, as mentioned by Luna, they are not totally weak, if they just spend a little bit of time during the casting time, they can produce a powerful output. Ohrun, basically remove the casting, cool down time, and add boost enchantments by his support magic.
Though the last part confused me, first scene they are accepting the truth and the second the hero became a douche.
Philly is cute, busty, has an flattering leg slit in her outfit, and seems like a genuinely nice person. She just had the bad luck of getting recruited to replace Orhun in the Hero's Party and immediately notice that the Hero's Party is wasting funds on throwing a party while throwing shade at Orhun at every chance they can. Oliver even calls him a "loser." Ugh.
And then Luna walks in and sees everyone celebrating and finds out what they did to Orhun...and she's the only one who fully realized back then how screwed they were without him, but nobody would listen to her. Even though she knew, like Orhun, that they shouldn't head deeper into the dungeon to train their new party formation.
And immediately the cracks begin showing: none of their attacks are as strong as they used to be, their defense isn't working, their magic isn't hitting as hard, and the buffs just aren't nearly as effective. They can't even defeat one laser mammoth without Orhun. And before Luna can even say "I told you so" the Black Dragon they wanted to avoid fighting above all else shows up to try to kill them.
They are SO out of their depth here. The attacks that actually worked on the Black Dragon no longer work and they're clearly no match for it this go-around. Even Oliver's signature move does nothing to it. And as if to make everything worse, their attempt to escape the Black Dragon only serves to send it to another floor, siccing it on another unsuspecting party. They REALLY screwed this one up.
And then Luna lays into them about how screwed they were without Orhun: how he was hard carrying them with his original magic buffs, with capacity far beyond what Philly thought was possible, and as a result Oliver, Derrick, and Anneli have all let their skills atrophy to the point where they're nowhere near as strong without him. They're basically a mid to lower rank party without Orhun at this point.
Everyone celebrating the Hero's Party when they're really running with their tail between their legs...and yet Oliver is STILL convinced they don't need Orhun. What a joke!
Did they just presume his buffs were weaker because they thought they were using their own strength? If so, why did this happen? Like, how did they come to the conclusion his buffs had nothing to do with their performance.
It feels like they randomly, without any evidence, simply decided MC wasn't good enough.
I was expecting some explanation like: even though his buffs weren't as strong as others, he was using those in a smart way, or smth like that... But when they stated that his buffs were stronger than Selma's the plot seemed to become a bit off to me.
Can someone help me figure this out?
So even if they were unaware of all the side-work Orhun was putting up in battle + unaware of his original spells, they would still have to conclude his buffs were better than Selma's.
I mean, as someone being buffed, the only thing that is actually perceived is how stronger one has become after getting a buff.
So I think my actual question is: how and why did they think Selma casted stronger buffs?
I think your theory of training absence makes sense. Maybe they really thought their actual power was that and Ohrun's buffs weren't as strong.
Honestly, I wish this wasn't the way the story was going. I would be way happier if Orhun was, instead, just really gifted at maintaining dozens of spells at once. Cast a Strength Up, Attack Up, and a Sharpness Up, then cast Defense Down on enemy, Weakness to Cutting, etc. (a 32x effective increase), while simultaneously doing the same for all of the other party members. Especially since it was stated even Selma struggles with debuffs or can't do them. So the overall strength of his magic is weak, but the sheer variety and mixing of them is the cause of his strength.
How did they join the childhood group in the first place and became very hateful to Orun.
Tank dude and wizzard girl seem like the worst out of the bunch. Altough they might stray from the delulu-path now that blue explained everything (again?), they behaved like utter trash beforehand. Either they realise how much they screwed up, or go down with captain-delulu trying to fight some insanely strong monsters without Ohrun.
I admire blue for trying to get them to understand just how essential Ohrun was for the party, even though I don't think it's going to work out. She definitely should give up on the arrogant pricks and join Ohrun.
Regarding the black dragon, obviously Ohrun is going to encounter it and clean up the mess the others left behind and I'm looking forward to it.
The complication shouldn't have come from them lacking power in the attacks but the strategy and approach they took in battle, I've getting severely injured and Luna being unable to heal them or from being unable to approach an enemy with an anti-dmg field or something insane that Orhun's learnt how to disable or temporarily interrupt.
What's still makes sense for me that they didn't notice:
- Orun individual support magic is weaker than others, however
- Orun can coordinate them perfectly
- Orun counted when the buff wear off, so it feels like they're always buffed at the right time
- Orun debuff the enemies as well (we've seen this)
- Orun buff both the teammates and their equipment at the correct time
That 50 times original magic seems like nothing that wouldn't be unnoticeable if they call him weak. Is it 50 times stronger or 50 times the duration? I'm unclear on that since that topic was brought up when they discussed about buff duration
Basically, the only dumbass people are the rest of the heroes party besides Luna, and Orhun himself for not recognizing his own level compared to the other enchanters. If he personally realized how good he actually is, he'd have more ground to stand on when he was trying to stay in the party.
But then it turns out the old guy was the only one keeping all the legacy systems up and running, coded the backend and knows that if you move the stuffed wombat in the janitor's closet on the third floor, you'll actually bring down the whole network(though even he doesn't know why that's so, but it always happens).
The rest of the party is like management at the business. They know they need an enchanter. But they have no effing clue what the hell they do to get results. So they default to the only metric they know:
Certifications.
She isn’t shown to be a pushover. She’s very outspoken. It makes no sense that she would agree to go when she knows how dangerous it is. I hope next episode is better.
The drago's one smart boss. Why limit itself to wiping out one weakling party when it can wipe out a whole bunch of weakling parties instead? I certainly hadn't expected the "Heroes" to fuck up in a way that would endanger so many others in the dungeon rather than just themselves.
You'd think that as they ran past all those parties outside the dungeon they'd warn them not to enter the dungeon.