What are differences between romance anime targeted at a male demographic and a female demographic
I haven’t watched a lot of romance anime aimed at male demographics, and I was wondering if there are any differences between the two. Which subgenres are more common, and what archetypes are common in one but not the other?
Commentaires
shoujo romance - hot guy and dorky girl
Same with shoujo probably being demographically targeted at girls
Especially because anime and manga to my knowledge is still more of a "nerdy" hobby in japan, with the entire "otaku culture" being in some parts still shamed, which is why its such a central theme of so many of them, especially in the whole "otaku guy gets accepted by the popular girl" kinda deal.
Though it cant be underestimated that both in the west and east you have an entire genre of "average girl / young woman gets the attraction of the hot guy / rich hot young ceo" basically the cinderella syndrome.
where while there exists shounen romance like "Golden Time" and "3D Girlfriend" its also why there is such a huge swath of harem series of "young guy gets all the hot girls to like him"
its all wishfullfilment.
A lot of anime at its core is wish fulfillment. Even to that, a lot of entertainment in the west is too. It’s just part and parcel of the media.
Honestly, most of the competent female leads I can think of come from works where the premise had a tinge of parody to it. The premise will be inherently comedy, but then the story gets serialized and gets pulled into being a romance.
the tropes are basically the same, it’s only who is more embarrassed that kinda changes. In shonen when a girl gets caught changing the guy will have a more over the top reaction because of the dorky virgin vibe. In shoujo the girl will have more of a reaction.
But both are prone to roughly the same fan service: panty shots, cleavage, jiggle physics, sexual innuendos and sexualized situations that are awkward to explain etc.
And you do get different romance tropes: the male lead getting flustered because she's looking unusually cute, multiple guys being interested in the female lead, the male lead being indifferent to the efforts of additional girls to catch his attention, kabe-don and similar moments of the male lead getting assertive, having an attractive male supporting cast even if they're not interested in the heroine just because, hey, they're nice to look at....
☝️🤓 Actually, Kaguya-sama is seinen…
Kare Kano is one although the anime made it more psychological than romance. The manga is more comedic in tone.
This usually happens when the FMC is caught off guard in some way
It’s often referred to as “shojo vision” as they are not literally in front of flowers but it is all in the mind of the FMC.
really i usually love the mc for example fruits basket or ouran highschool host club or kamisama kiss i mean i love the love interests but how are they meant to be relatable without a personality
Of course, not every protagonist is an empty shell for self-insert, but I think you get the gist of what I'm trying to say, compared to shōjo which (I say this as someone with a more superficial knowledge of this demographic) seems more focused on the love story itself.
I am a guy and I also like "guy things" as well, but for me I don't think about this kind of story telling being for men or woman, I just think it is good story telling because it feels meaningful.
But also shonen romance is USUALLY written by males, while shojo by females. And the issue is that you will always struggle to properly write characters of opposite sex than your own, especially when it comes to romance.
Men will struggle to realistically write female characters and women will struggle to realistically write male characters (again - USUALLY; FMAB was made by woman and I would never guess that since male characters were actually realistic - but FMAB is not a romance).
The reason while I personally dislike a lot of shojo romances (including novels if we could put them into this category - for an example "Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou desu") are shitty male characters. I enjoy females in those titles, but guys are absolute garbage.
The shoujo I've liked generally tend to not be pure romance aside from maybe Nana.
Male demographic: fragrant flower blooms with dignity.
These are prolly the deepest they go meta wise. Anyways jokes aside it's just loser girl pretty boy (female demographic) and loser boy pretty girl (male demographic) fan service tropes are the same for the most part.
Does the story feel like a male fantasy or a female one.
Of course it’s more complicated that and I am not saying these things don’t exist in shojo, but how they are portrayed.
An older female protagonist doesn't make a Josei. Hell, most of the cute girls do cute things like K-On and Yuru camp are seinen.
*Monthly Big Gangan* and *Monthly Sunday Gene-X*, both are classifed as seinen magazine.
But it is understandable that random site classify it as josei. It SHOULD be one, but by fact it ain't. That is why the whole shonen/shojo/seinen/josei is generally irrelevant. It is just which magazine licensed it.
Romance aimed at boys is usually more unrealistic, blissful, and simple minded: the girl just loves the boy no matter what and nothing ever shakes the foundation of their relationship, often times multiple girls love him and everyone is just weirdly okay with that, the male main characters are often oblivious
I admit I don't always watch male-targeted romances either, because the "average guy paired with angelically beautiful honor student who's an excellent cook and enjoys doing laundry" formula doesn't have much to offer me. But I do watch some, and some of the standouts I've enjoyed are actually male-targeted, shounen or seinen titles: Kaguya-sama, My Dress-Up Darling, 100 Girlfriends... maybe Ranma 1/2?
I think some of the differences you're interested in have to do with what gets adapted: I just named three/four romcoms aimed at a male audience (partly because I prefer romcoms to pure romance) and yet the only shoujo romcom I can think of recently is Tamon's B-Side. The mangaka's earlier, long-running romcom, Takane & Hana, didn't get an anime at all. I think shoujo and josei titles these days are likelier to get a single cour (or a live-action adaptation) and they're likelier to pick dramas and pure romances over comedies.
Male-targeted romances probably aren't any more likely to be harems than shoujo/josei shows are to be reverse harems, but harem shows may be more likely to get adapted because you can sell more waifu merch that way.
I think male-targeted romances are less likely to have the male lead being assertive (kabe-don moments, the male lead getting all possessive over the heroine, etc.) and are more likely to have the male lead's insecurities and emotional progression being the focus. That sounds kind of funny when I just referenced Tamon's B-Side - but Tamon's insecurity is more of a running gag than an emotional thing, and we spend a lot more time in Utage's head than in Tamon's.
A lot of it's just point of view. Like, the first episode of "The Fragrant Flower Blooms With Dignity" sets up the premise of the rival schools, has the female lead eating at the bakery where the male lead works, she gets the doki-dokis from him, goes to walk home, gets accosted by some guys, and the male lead comes to her rescue, but not before she gives an earnest speech in defense of him. The whole sequence of events could absolutely happen in shoujo (though her *telling* him she had a doki-doki moment would be unusual) but this time it's all from the guy's point of view, and the character designs have him looking more average while she's beautiful.
(But then you also get shoujo series like Ore Monogatari that are told from the guy's point of view and where the guy is definitely not handsome while she's adorable. Yet Ore Monogatari *feels* shoujo. I don't know how to explain it.)
There are exceptions of course, but that's how it often is.
Basically I think this gives Horimiya a unique feel as its not really strictly shonen or shoujo. Helps explain why its so broadly popular too.
But to answer your question, as someone who’s watched a ton of both, there’s not really much difference when you compare the two (granted you’re comparing two of similar types of show like I mentioned). Both involve the MC being the “less desirable”, whether they are the average guy/girl or the bullied girl or the loner guy, and the love interest is someone who’d usually be someone out of their league who takes an interest in them. And the reason is usually cos they are hard worker or kind or earnest or something along that line. I don’t really like saying one person is “above or below” the other but just for the purpose of this discussion and also cos the characters we’re talking about are fictional, I’ll refer to them that way.
Look at shows like Blue Box, Fragrant Flower, Golden Time, Dress Up Darling, Bokuyaba for male targetted. And for female targetted, Sign of Affection, Kimi ni Todoke, Say I Love You, Itazura na Kiss, Fruits Basket, Honey Lemon Soda.
Of course not all are like that. Some shows have them, I feel, at a more equal standing like Lovely Complex or Toradora.
But bottomline is, if you’ve watched female demographic romance, then for male demographic the intent is similar. If girls want a cool, confident guy as a love interest, guys want a gentle, kind girl as a love interest. Not the same tastes but same intent for the audience. Two sides of the same coin
I can confidently say the surefire difference is the protagonist.
Male protagonist = aimed at males
Female protagonist = aimed at females
Both demographics usually want the person from the other gender being good looking, gentile, loyal, hardworking and usually quite proactive.
I feel like there is a lot of copying between the two with things that look good in one of them.
The example (no anime unfortunatly) I like to have is "Black Madougushi Guild wo Tsuihousareta Watashi, Oukyuu Majutsushi to shite Hirowareru." and "Souzou Renkinjutsushi wa Jiyuu wo Ouka Suru: Furusato wo Tsuihou Saretara, Maou no Hizamoto de Chouzetsu Kouka no Magic Item Tsukuri Houdai ni Narimashita.", which follow an surprisingly similar plotline, but with different gender roles.
I think the biggest difference is probably between male-male romance targeted at a female demographic and female-female romance targeted at a male demographic. The male-male one is described as often quite physically and usually is a core aspect of the story. The female-female one is usually lightharted and rarely exists apart form as a sidekick in the "cute girls doing cute things"/"moeblob" genre.
For male-female romance I would say the stories with a harem setup aimed at females rarely get adapted into anime, let alone being adapted into the West, while those aimed at a male audience often do.
One thing I also notice is that good male-aimed romance stories work with a kind of "Came for the lewd teaser, stayed for the solid romance." recipie, which I have never seen the other way around.
Worst romance anime for male demographics in my very personal opinion is probably "To Love Ru". Best romance anime is hard to tell, as I find a reason why to not list it for virtually every show.
Not: they get together at the end of the series